1. notleia says:

    This is so Poe’s Law that it almost hurts.

  2. Autumn Grayson says:

    Great way to parody the way people demand that media change to fit their causes :). I see some people demanding that superheroes normally portrayed as straight should suddenly be turned gay in the actual canon of their stories.  To me it would make more sense if they would ask that a new gay superhero was invented, rather than forcing people to completely alter an existing hero.

    An article I read one time was talking about some Walking Dead character and how the fans wanted that character to come out as gay.  One person said something along the lines of ‘this character is a nice person, so I think he should be gay because gay people are kind.’. So they seemed to think that the show needed to educate people on how nice most gay people apparently are.  Or that there are far more kind gay people than there are straight people, so much so that it would be better or more realistic to portray this beloved, kind character as gay.  If one wanted to be sensitive about this issue, they could see that whole idea as an insult to straight people.

    If the makers of Walking Dead want to make their character a certain way, that is their choice.  Personally, I kinda dislike it when fans demand that an author write certain types of characters and stories, as if it is the author’s job to represent minorities, or as if the fans partially own a story and have a right to decide what happens in it.  Having character diversity is great, but as a girl of mixed ancestry I don’t automatically see authors as racist or sexist just because they don’t feature characters like me.  If I don’t like a book, I might rant about it to a friend or talk about why I find the views in it problematic, but I don’t call the author horrible for not changing their writing to fit my views.  They can write what they want, and if I don’t like it I read something else.  People may call me a bigot for thinking that, but I don’t think that is an unfair way to think, considering that even though religious people are often persecuted or looked down on and are under represented in media I don’t freak out at authors for not cranking out tons of accurately portrayed religious characters.  But if people truly want diversity in stories, they will allow even the voices they dislike to remain in media, and if any specific representation is needed, the complainers can represent a minority within their own published works, rather than demanding that authors change the way they write.

    @Leah:  Yeah, I agree that a lot of people might miss the point of this article. 

    • Eric says:

      I wish more fandoms had your attitude, Autumn

        • Autumn Grayson says:

          Neat article, thanks for sharing! 🙂

          It’s really interesting to me, because growing up I’ve had a vastly different experience with the characters I liked and identified with. I’m half white and half Latino. But I never really felt marginalized, and I didn’t identify with characters based on race. I usually just liked the characters that happened to seem cool to me. Either that or the ones I made an emotional connection to because I identified with them. Many times that was the main guy character. And I think that was because growing up I wanted to be taken seriously on some level and to be able to handle whatever life threw at me. Many guy characters in stories exhibited that, along with having interesting backstories(and I love characters with cool backstories).

          To be honest, there were many times when I didn’t even recognize a characters race, or at least not for a long time. When I did notice, it was slightly interesting for me, but that was all. It didn’t matter to me, because all I wanted was to watch cool characters in a cool show. So I guess I can’t help but feel that the representation issue isn’t just a matter of people not showing more racial or gender diversity in media. I think it’s also a matter of how we condition people to react. If we want to be truly free of racism and other forms of prejudice, I think we would teach our children that they can identify with characters of a different race. They can also look at characters of a different gender and empathize with personality traits they have in common, rather than freaking out at the lack of female characters.

          I certainly think we need to add character variety, but I know that I was spared a lot of hurt and resentment by not feeling marginalized just because there were not enough characters of my race or gender in the media. Honestly, I think the idea of trying to meet a ‘race or gender quota’ with characters creates more animosity, because people are like ‘we need this quota because our enemies still look down on us for being a minority, and only forcing a quota will fix it’.

          Interestingly enough, a major arc in one of my stories involves a Japan like country, so there will be a large variety of Asians(or at least a fantasy world equivalent) there. I didn’t do that to make a race quota. I did that because I had an idea for a story involving yokai, and having an Asian like country in that setting just made sense, and I could reasonably work it in given the history of that particular story world. I think it’s a million times better for character variety to come out of situations like that, where an author loves the characters and will make the story amazing because they are passionate about it, not just to represent a certain group.(Though I don’t think trying to represent a certain group automatically makes a bad story)

          I guess what saddens me is that people want representation, but then authors have a very hard time pleasing many people they may be representing, no matter how good a job they do. Honestly, that’s one big reason I would shy away from writing LGBT chars.

          Sorry for the essay, I can’t seem to say anything very concisely 😛

  3. Mark Carver says:

    #EdwardFindsSalvationintheBloodofChrist
    #FellowshipBaptistChurchoftheRing
    #StarTrekFirstCommunion
    #IronManPutsontheArmorofGod

  4. Lisa Smith says:

    I Just Can’t Even….

    It’s actually depressing reading this, because it is too close to the truth. Ack.

    That being said, however….how about:

    #MakeChristianGreyChristian
    #BridemaidsOfChrist
    #AvengersAreMineSaithTheLord
    #Creed:NotJustForBoxers

    • Some of those make a little more sense than, say, the parasitic notion of making Elsa a lesbian or Captain America a homoesexual for no reason other than “we want it.” For example, of “avenging”-style heroics is at least loosely tied to what God does!

What do you think?